Why Does Russia Alone Go Its Own Way, Apart From Europe?
The rest of Europe gets along, so why does Russia stay out of the EU, go its own way, and keep fighting? I was curious, so I looked for the reasons.
In Europe, kings, popes, nobles, self-governing cities, and the merchant class fought fiercely with one another. As a result, the ideas of parliament, rule of law, and contracts grew over hundreds of years. European integration presupposes conditions such as rule of law, separation of powers, democracy, and press freedom.
Russia's power structure, however, has continued as strong centralization and authoritarianism.
The nobles were merely the tsar's servants and never became a counterweight; independent cities and the merchant class were weak; and serfdom lasted until 1861.
Even the Russian Orthodox Church, which could have checked the state, was turned into a government department by Peter the Great.
Germany joined after being completely defeated and occupied in World War II and having its institutions rebuilt from the ground up.
France joined while exhausted by war, and as a founding member that made the rules.
Russia also lost the Cold War, but it kept its nuclear weapons and its permanent seat on the UN Security Council.
Russia wants special treatment as a great power.
Russian intellectuals have been fighting a family feud for more than 200 years. The Westernizers are the "we should live like Europe" camp, wanting to learn and catch up with Europe's parliaments, rule of law, and markets. The Slavophiles are the "copy the neighbors and you'll ruin the family" camp.
In the 1990s, the Westernizers finally took power and carried out Western-style reforms after the collapse of the Soviet Union. The result was economic collapse, oligarchs plundering the nation's wealth, and national humiliation.
Since the full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022, the possibility of integration between Russia and Europe has effectively vanished.
First, Russia's Politics and Society Are Different
In Europe, kings, popes, nobles, self-governing cities, and the merchant class fought fiercely with one another. As a result, the ideas of parliament, rule of law, and contracts grew over hundreds of years. European integration presupposes conditions such as rule of law, separation of powers, democracy, and press freedom.
Russia's power structure, however, has continued as strong centralization and authoritarianism.
The nobles were merely the tsar's servants and never became a counterweight; independent cities and the merchant class were weak; and serfdom lasted until 1861.
Even the Russian Orthodox Church, which could have checked the state, was turned into a government department by Peter the Great.
Second, Russia Wants to Be Treated as a Great Power
Germany joined after being completely defeated and occupied in World War II and having its institutions rebuilt from the ground up.
France joined while exhausted by war, and as a founding member that made the rules.
Russia also lost the Cold War, but it kept its nuclear weapons and its permanent seat on the UN Security Council.
Russia wants special treatment as a great power.
Third, Russia Tried to Imitate Europe and It Ended Badly
Russian intellectuals have been fighting a family feud for more than 200 years. The Westernizers are the "we should live like Europe" camp, wanting to learn and catch up with Europe's parliaments, rule of law, and markets. The Slavophiles are the "copy the neighbors and you'll ruin the family" camp.
In the 1990s, the Westernizers finally took power and carried out Western-style reforms after the collapse of the Soviet Union. The result was economic collapse, oligarchs plundering the nation's wealth, and national humiliation.
Since the full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022, the possibility of integration between Russia and Europe has effectively vanished.
- The Fall of Russia, Which Offered a Fake Tithe
- A Thousand Years of Tithing, and How Europe Came to Rule the World