Hayera Mystery — uncovering the hidden stories behind mysteries, society, politics, money, the mind and science

Hayera Mystery
Society

The "Dictatorship, Meddling, and Bullying" Culture That Confucianism Created

· Words & art by Hayera Mystery
The "Dictatorship, Meddling, and Bullying" Culture That Confucianism Created — Society
The "Dictatorship, Meddling, and Bullying" Culture That Confucianism Created · Hayera Mystery (Free to use)
When people think of Korean tradition, they think of Confucianism. Honor your parents, respect your elders, mind your manners. But shamanism, with shamans performing rituals and telling fortunes, has also existed for a very long time. The figures on South Korea's banknotes today are King Sejong, Shin Saimdang, Yi Hwang, and Yi I; Yi Hwang and Yi I were Confucian scholars, and Sejong was the representative monarch of the Confucian state of Joseon, so most of them are "figures connected to the Confucian tradition."

Loyalty: Loyalty Turns Into Dictatorship


The word for loyalty, chung, originally meant "to do something sincerely with all your heart." Old Confucian texts considered it a subject's duty to stand up to the king and say, "That was wrong of you," and Mencius even said, "If the king is a disaster, he can be replaced." Originally it was a two-way relationship.

But as the idea that one must be loyal to the king grew stronger, "listening well to the king" came to be seen as more admirable than "telling the king he's wrong." Even now it goes like this: "The boss told you to, so just do it." "It's your senior talking, so listen." Part-timers and new employees in particular find it hard to refuse even absurd instructions. The moment loyalty becomes not "let's all do well together" but "bow and scrape to those above," it turns into a culture of crushing people from above.

Filial Piety: Filial Duty Turns Into Meddling


When filial piety hardens into "parents have the right to command, children have the duty to obey," parents decide their children's careers and marriages, interfere in how they live, and take it for granted that the daughter-in-law will wait on her in-laws. Filial piety becomes not love but unconditional obedience.

Here's a twist. The hard life of a married woman in her husband's family that we believe has been a tradition since ancient times (the suffering of daughters-in-law, being saddled with ancestral rites, everything centered on the son's family) was actually fixed in the late Joseon period, about 400 years ago. Before that, in Goryeo and early Joseon, it was common for a man to live with his wife's family, daughters inherited property equally, and sons and daughters took turns holding ancestral rites. "That's how a daughter-in-law is supposed to be" is half wrong.

Propriety: Manners Turn Into Rank


Manners were originally about respecting the other person. But in Korea they became a tool for confirming who is above whom. If you're older, you can talk down to others; if your rank is higher, you can treat people carelessly; if you joined first, rudeness to juniors gets overlooked. How does being born one month earlier than me give you the right to treat me carelessly? When rank comes before people, manners become a procedure for confirming "I'm above you" and the wrapping paper for bullying.

Why It Got Twisted: From Mutual to One-Way


Originally, Confucianism had a give-and-take relationship. "Let the king be a king, and the subject a subject." If the king didn't act like a king, the subject had no reason to follow. But later, the one-way idea grew stronger: "The king, the father, and the husband are the standard, and those below must conform no matter what." This is where the structure of "those above command, those below obey" came from. So loyalty became "obey," filial piety became "follow your parents' will," and propriety became "those below must conform," leading to dictatorship between king and subject, meddling between parents and children, conflict between in-laws and daughters-in-law, crushing from above at the office, and bullying between seniors and juniors.

Shamanism: Blessing Turns Into Greed


Shamanism treats the blessings of this present world as most important: health, children's success, business, money. When this goes too far, the goal of life shrinks to "how well things go for me." When making money, buying a house, and growing your assets become blessing itself, your family's interests always come before living a good life. If Confucianism bound people in relationships of above and below, shamanism binds them to money and greed.

Conclusion


Tradition itself isn't bad. Confucianism had values of caring for others and living a good life, and also the idea that "even the king must do right." Shamanism also long comforted people's troubled hearts. The problem is the point at which these get twisted into bowing and scraping, rank, money, and selfishness.
Read the original (Korean) →
More stories
Number One in the World for Loving Money: South Korea, Land of Confucianism and Buddhism
Number One in the World for Loving Money: South Korea, Land of Confucianism and Buddhism
Why Evolution Videos Never Show the Other Side
Why Evolution Videos Never Show the Other Side
A Lawsuit Paradise 2,000 Years Ago Too, and Paul Opposed It
A Lawsuit Paradise 2,000 Years Ago Too, and Paul Opposed It
The Impossible Crumbles Before Your Faith
The Impossible Crumbles Before Your Faith
The Plot Holes in the "Godlike" Reptilian Illuminati Theory
The Plot Holes in the "Godlike" Reptilian Illuminati Theory
Every Sexual Pleasure Turns Into "Fear" and Comes Back at You
Every Sexual Pleasure Turns Into "Fear" and Comes Back at You
All words and pictures on Hayera Mystery are free to use, no credit needed.
Corrections: yupeifeng@naver.com