The Trap of the Talisman: A 99% Profit Margin Product
These days talismans are sold everywhere: to ward off bad luck, to bring money, to pass exams, for health, you name it. A single sheet of paper with a few characters written on it supposedly solves every problem in life. Is that really so? Let's leave emotion aside and go through it point by point.
A plate of pasta includes noodles, sauce, ingredients, labor, and rent. A talisman is done with a sheet of paper and a few characters. The cost is about the price of paper and ink. Yet what it promises is enormous: it blocks bad luck, calls in money, ties love together, gets you through exams, prevents illness, and protects your household. The cost is one sheet of paper, but the product description is a miracle cure-all. It's an extreme-margin product.
A research team at the University of Cologne told people, "This is a lucky ball," and had them putt golf balls. Those who heard that sank more putts. People who did a memory game while holding their own lucky charm also scored better. But when other research teams repeated the same experiments, the effect vanished. The replication failed. It was a flash in the pan.
Even more remarkable is this. A Harvard research team gave patients pills while telling them outright, "This is a sugar pill with no active ingredients." The bottle was even printed with the word "placebo." Yet the patients' irritable bowel syndrome symptoms improved. Even though no one forced them to believe, their bodies responded.
Here, a line is drawn. Pain, insomnia, and anxiety respond briefly to expectation. Tumor size, blood sugar, and infection do not. So "I felt at ease after putting up a talisman" is a possible statement, but "the cancer disappeared after I put up a talisman" is a claim of an entirely different category. To claim the latter, you'd need scans and test records, and there are none.
You buy a talisman for passing an exam. "Now I'll make it." You study less. You buy a wealth talisman. "Money will come in." You stop managing your spending. You buy a health talisman. "I'll be fine." You put off your checkup. The problem isn't the talisman. It's the moment when relief takes the place of action.
Anxiety is originally a warning system telling you, "There's a problem, so prepare." If a talisman turns off anxiety too quickly, the problem stays the same and only your mind is at ease. A problem without a plan eventually jumps out in reality.
In fact, an analysis combining 46 studies and 25,000 participants found that the more people believed "my health is decided by luck and fate anyway," the less preventive action they took. In particular, they got fewer cancer screenings. When the mind's warning system is turned off, the body pays the price instead.
First, There's No Better Value Product in the World
A plate of pasta includes noodles, sauce, ingredients, labor, and rent. A talisman is done with a sheet of paper and a few characters. The cost is about the price of paper and ink. Yet what it promises is enormous: it blocks bad luck, calls in money, ties love together, gets you through exams, prevents illness, and protects your household. The cost is one sheet of paper, but the product description is a miracle cure-all. It's an extreme-margin product.
Second, Experiments Show the Effect Is Only a Flash
A research team at the University of Cologne told people, "This is a lucky ball," and had them putt golf balls. Those who heard that sank more putts. People who did a memory game while holding their own lucky charm also scored better. But when other research teams repeated the same experiments, the effect vanished. The replication failed. It was a flash in the pan.
Even more remarkable is this. A Harvard research team gave patients pills while telling them outright, "This is a sugar pill with no active ingredients." The bottle was even printed with the word "placebo." Yet the patients' irritable bowel syndrome symptoms improved. Even though no one forced them to believe, their bodies responded.
Here, a line is drawn. Pain, insomnia, and anxiety respond briefly to expectation. Tumor size, blood sugar, and infection do not. So "I felt at ease after putting up a talisman" is a possible statement, but "the cancer disappeared after I put up a talisman" is a claim of an entirely different category. To claim the latter, you'd need scans and test records, and there are none.
Third, the Warning System Gets Switched Off
You buy a talisman for passing an exam. "Now I'll make it." You study less. You buy a wealth talisman. "Money will come in." You stop managing your spending. You buy a health talisman. "I'll be fine." You put off your checkup. The problem isn't the talisman. It's the moment when relief takes the place of action.
Anxiety is originally a warning system telling you, "There's a problem, so prepare." If a talisman turns off anxiety too quickly, the problem stays the same and only your mind is at ease. A problem without a plan eventually jumps out in reality.
In fact, an analysis combining 46 studies and 25,000 participants found that the more people believed "my health is decided by luck and fate anyway," the less preventive action they took. In particular, they got fewer cancer screenings. When the mind's warning system is turned off, the body pays the price instead.
- Perpetual Motion Exists: The "Idol of Images"
- Perpetual Motion Exists: The "Energy Idol"
- The "Idol Series" That Gives Scientists a Headache
- Is Falun Gong's "Falun" Healing Really Cosmic Energy?