Iran's Regime: A Don Quixote Charging at Windmills
In Cervantes' novel, Don Quixote mistakes ordinary windmills for giant monsters and levels his lance at them.
He believed he was a knight of justice, but to those around him he was a pitiful sight.
Iran's ruling regime can look the same to its neighbors, because it seems to keep using religion as political cover to create enemies that don't really exist. This is a criticism of a government's politics, not of Islam or of the Iranian people.
Iran is a Shia state whose tradition holds that only the "Twelve Imams," descendants of Ali, the son-in-law of the Prophet Muhammad, are the rightful leaders.
When the last of them went into occultation in 874, the line of leadership was broken, and centuries later the ruling clerics concluded that they themselves should govern in the meantime.
Yet the regime turns around and accuses other Muslim governments, such as Saudi Arabia, of being "illegitimate regimes," even though by its own account its power is only that of a "temporary deputy."
Iran's government denies Israel's very right to exist and brands it "an invader that stole someone else's land," but its own footing is different.
Iran holds by force three islands (Abu Musa and others) whose ownership is disputed with its neighbor, the United Arab Emirates.
It runs on a miraculous logic: Israel reclaiming ancient land is "aggression," but Iran occupying Arab islands is "restoring original territory."
The memory of the 1953 coup, when U.S. CIA involvement toppled a democratic government, branded America as the "Great Satan" in many Iranians' minds.
The regime says it hates violations of other countries' sovereignty, yet it steers proxy forces such as Hezbollah (Lebanon), the Houthis (Yemen), and militias (Iraq), dragging the whole Middle East into the pit of civil war.
American intervention is "the devil's mischief," but the regime's destabilization of other countries is dressed up as "a holy struggle to spread the Islamic Revolution."
Iran's leadership applies strict moral standards, claiming that Western capitalism and decadent culture destroy the Muslim family and community.
Luxurious hypocrisy: Meanwhile, the children of the elite (the so-called "aghazadeh") show off supercars and designer bags on Instagram, enjoying the sweet fruits of the West.
The contradiction in education: While they agitate that "Western education is a poison that eats away at the Islamic spirit," the children of high officials head to elite universities in the U.S., the U.K., and Canada and work hard to obtain residency in "the land of Satan."
When racism controversies break out in the United States, the regime raises its voice in criticism as if it were a defender of human rights.
Yet at home, 22-year-old Mahsa Amini died in custody after being detained for not wearing her hijab properly, and the young people who protested were branded "enemies of God" and sent to the gallows.
And today, it seems, the regime once again reaches for religious language to find its next enemy.
He believed he was a knight of justice, but to those around him he was a pitiful sight.
Iran's ruling regime can look the same to its neighbors, because it seems to keep using religion as political cover to create enemies that don't really exist. This is a criticism of a government's politics, not of Islam or of the Iranian people.
1. The Bloodline Ended, but the Clerics Won't Let Go of Power
Iran is a Shia state whose tradition holds that only the "Twelve Imams," descendants of Ali, the son-in-law of the Prophet Muhammad, are the rightful leaders.
When the last of them went into occultation in 874, the line of leadership was broken, and centuries later the ruling clerics concluded that they themselves should govern in the meantime.
Yet the regime turns around and accuses other Muslim governments, such as Saudi Arabia, of being "illegitimate regimes," even though by its own account its power is only that of a "temporary deputy."
2. When We Do It, It's Restoring Territory; When Others Do It, It's Occupation
Iran's government denies Israel's very right to exist and brands it "an invader that stole someone else's land," but its own footing is different.
Iran holds by force three islands (Abu Musa and others) whose ownership is disputed with its neighbor, the United Arab Emirates.
It runs on a miraculous logic: Israel reclaiming ancient land is "aggression," but Iran occupying Arab islands is "restoring original territory."
3. America Is the Devil, but the Militias We Back Are Holy Warriors
The memory of the 1953 coup, when U.S. CIA involvement toppled a democratic government, branded America as the "Great Satan" in many Iranians' minds.
The regime says it hates violations of other countries' sovereignty, yet it steers proxy forces such as Hezbollah (Lebanon), the Houthis (Yemen), and militias (Iraq), dragging the whole Middle East into the pit of civil war.
American intervention is "the devil's mischief," but the regime's destabilization of other countries is dressed up as "a holy struggle to spread the Islamic Revolution."
4. Western Culture Is Poison, but Our Children Are Studying Abroad
Iran's leadership applies strict moral standards, claiming that Western capitalism and decadent culture destroy the Muslim family and community.
Luxurious hypocrisy: Meanwhile, the children of the elite (the so-called "aghazadeh") show off supercars and designer bags on Instagram, enjoying the sweet fruits of the West.
The contradiction in education: While they agitate that "Western education is a poison that eats away at the Islamic spirit," the children of high officials head to elite universities in the U.S., the U.K., and Canada and work hard to obtain residency in "the land of Satan."
5. Outraged by Racism, Silent on Violence Against Women
When racism controversies break out in the United States, the regime raises its voice in criticism as if it were a defender of human rights.
Yet at home, 22-year-old Mahsa Amini died in custody after being detained for not wearing her hijab properly, and the young people who protested were branded "enemies of God" and sent to the gallows.
And today, it seems, the regime once again reaches for religious language to find its next enemy.
- How Islam's Doctrine Shifted to Justify Conquest
- How Islam Put a Gag on God's Voice
- Iran vs. Israel: A Family Feud Over an Inheritance
- The Vanishing Alien Baby and the Book of Mormon
- Was Muhammad Originally a Christian?
- Is Islam an "Upgrade" of Christianity?
- Did Iran's Leader Khamenei Go to Heaven? Three AIs Answer