Calvin vs. Wesley: How Your Future Was "Chosen"
Is our future predestined? The 500-year marital spat that never ends is the debate between Calvin's predestination and Wesley's foreknowledge.
I want to end this fight today. This problem can't be solved with classical theology alone. It can be explained easily only by a theologian who can do programming, the kind used in backtesting. To give the conclusion first: both are right. And the two were originally one.
Calvin says God decided who would be saved before He even made the world.
But ask Uncle Calvin this and things get awkward: "So am I a puppet? If everything's decided, what is my choice?"
"Do unbelievers not believe because God decided they wouldn't? Then is it their fault or God's?"
Here Uncle Calvin gets a bit tongue-tied. Thin freedom is this position's weak spot.
So Wesley strikes back. God didn't force anything. He simply knew in advance who would believe. He didn't decide; He knew.
But Uncle Wesley has a tricky question too.
"If God already knows my whole future, isn't that future already fixed? Doesn't He know it because it's fixed? Then can I really choose differently?"
Here Uncle Wesley starts to sweat a little. He only said "knows," but a future locked into a single path looks just like Calvin's.
Here's the interesting part. The two uncles are fighting so hard, but they're actually standing in the same spot.
Both assume God's gaze is fixed on "this particular decision of yours." That's the trap.
Both have put God in too small a place, as if He were peering over my shoulder to see whether I'll order noodles or soup. Change this picture, and the fight ends.
What God decided isn't "whether you'll pick the noodles or the soup."
What God chose is "the whole world in which you can freely pick either."
A game developer doesn't control whether a character goes left or right. Instead, they build the whole thing with every possibility accounted for, and switch it on.
God is like that. There are countless worlds God could make. He knows them all, the endless worlds where people freely live this way or that. Out of them, He chose the one world where His will unfolds most beautifully, and made it real.
So God's interest wasn't "your lunch," but "the whole world in which a free person called you lives." The scale was completely different.
In today's terms, God ran every possible simulation and executed one of them. People long ago just didn't have the words for this picture.
First, God knows every possible free world. Wait, that's Wesley's "foreknowledge"!
Second, He chooses the best one and switches it on. Wait, that's Calvin's "decree"!
The two uncles fought for 500 years, each saying the other was wrong, but it turns out each was holding the front half and the back half of the same motion.
So your choice is 100 percent real. This world is woven together right down to the moment you pray and God answers.
That's why prophecy is possible, and why you sometimes glimpse the future in a dream. The world is already fully written, and a fragment of the script sometimes leaks out in a dream.
The 500-year marital spat ends here, today.
I want to end this fight today. This problem can't be solved with classical theology alone. It can be explained easily only by a theologian who can do programming, the kind used in backtesting. To give the conclusion first: both are right. And the two were originally one.
1. Uncle Calvin's claim: "God decided everything"
Calvin says God decided who would be saved before He even made the world.
But ask Uncle Calvin this and things get awkward: "So am I a puppet? If everything's decided, what is my choice?"
"Do unbelievers not believe because God decided they wouldn't? Then is it their fault or God's?"
Here Uncle Calvin gets a bit tongue-tied. Thin freedom is this position's weak spot.
2. Uncle Wesley strikes back: "God only knew"
So Wesley strikes back. God didn't force anything. He simply knew in advance who would believe. He didn't decide; He knew.
But Uncle Wesley has a tricky question too.
"If God already knows my whole future, isn't that future already fixed? Doesn't He know it because it's fixed? Then can I really choose differently?"
Here Uncle Wesley starts to sweat a little. He only said "knows," but a future locked into a single path looks just like Calvin's.
3. Wait, they're fighting in a strange place
Here's the interesting part. The two uncles are fighting so hard, but they're actually standing in the same spot.
Both assume God's gaze is fixed on "this particular decision of yours." That's the trap.
Both have put God in too small a place, as if He were peering over my shoulder to see whether I'll order noodles or soup. Change this picture, and the fight ends.
4. God isn't interested in your lunch order
What God decided isn't "whether you'll pick the noodles or the soup."
What God chose is "the whole world in which you can freely pick either."
A game developer doesn't control whether a character goes left or right. Instead, they build the whole thing with every possibility accounted for, and switch it on.
God is like that. There are countless worlds God could make. He knows them all, the endless worlds where people freely live this way or that. Out of them, He chose the one world where His will unfolds most beautifully, and made it real.
So God's interest wasn't "your lunch," but "the whole world in which a free person called you lives." The scale was completely different.
In today's terms, God ran every possible simulation and executed one of them. People long ago just didn't have the words for this picture.
5. Calvin and Wesley were actually on the same team
First, God knows every possible free world. Wait, that's Wesley's "foreknowledge"!
Second, He chooses the best one and switches it on. Wait, that's Calvin's "decree"!
The two uncles fought for 500 years, each saying the other was wrong, but it turns out each was holding the front half and the back half of the same motion.
So your choice is 100 percent real. This world is woven together right down to the moment you pray and God answers.
That's why prophecy is possible, and why you sometimes glimpse the future in a dream. The world is already fully written, and a fragment of the script sometimes leaks out in a dream.
The 500-year marital spat ends here, today.
- What If Every Prayer Were Answered?
- The Impossible Crumbles Before Your Faith
- When Did Sermons Become So Boring?